
Court Rejects Thompson’s WIFOL Lawsuit, Orders Handover of Union Property Within Seven Days
~ Former union chairman prohibited from acting on WIFOL’s behalf and faces penalties of up to Cg. 50,000 for noncompliance ~
Philipsburg, St. Maarten – November 15, 2026… The Court of First Instance of Sint Maarten has dismissed a lawsuit filed by longtime Workers Institute for Organized Labor (WIFOL) chairman Theophilus Emanuel Thompson challenging the appointment of a new union board, while ordering him to surrender the organization’s property, administrative records, passwords and financial access within seven days.
In a judgment delivered on Friday, November 13, 2026, Judge G. Konings also prohibited Thompson from presenting himself as WIFOL’s chairman, director or representative, effective immediately.
The ruling brings a decisive development in a leadership dispute that followed an extraordinary general membership meeting on September 17, 2026, during which a new board was elected under the chairmanship of Joanice David Richardson.
The court ordered Thompson to pay litigation costs totaling Cg. 3,000 and imposed a penalty of Cg. 2,500 per day, up to a maximum of Cg. 50,000, if he fails to comply with the court’s orders.
Members Initiated Leadership Change
According to the judgment, Thompson had been involved in WIFOL’s leadership since 1983, including its predecessor organization, and had served as chairman since at least the association’s establishment under its current statutes in 2013.
On May 7, 2026, ten union members submitted a written request for the board to convene an extraordinary general membership meeting.
When the board failed to act within the two-week period prescribed by WIFOL’s statutes, the requesting members exercised their statutory right to convene the meeting themselves.
The meeting was subsequently scheduled for September 17, 2026.
Its agenda included the board’s report, financial documents, the audit committee’s report, the filling of board vacancies and the appointment of a new audit committee.
During the meeting, Thompson’s removal as chairman was addressed and a new board was elected, consisting of Richardson as chairperson, Elton Achille Jones and Lesley Asma Berkel.
Thompson refused to recognize the legal validity of the meeting and its decisions.
Thompson Challenged Election Procedures
On October 8, 2026, Thompson initiated summary proceedings against WIFOL and members of its newly elected board.
He argued that the September 17 meeting had not complied with the association’s statutory requirements.
His objections included allegations that the election had been conducted by acclamation or applause rather than written ballots, that the required quorum had not been present and that the meeting had not been properly convened as a subsequent or repeated general meeting.
Thompson requested that the court provisionally declare the meeting’s decisions invalid, suspend the new board’s demands for the surrender of WIFOL property and prohibit the newly elected directors from acting on behalf of the union.
He also sought an arrangement for interim representation of WIFOL pending further legal proceedings.
However, the case took a significant turn during the October 30 hearing.
Thompson Withdrew His Main Objections
In paragraph 4.2 of the judgment, the court recorded that Thompson withdrew all three substantive objections concerning the legality of the September 17 meeting.
The court noted that the defendants’ submissions established, among other things, that an agenda had been circulated, members had attended the meeting and voting slips had been used in the election of the new board.
Thompson also referred to a provision of WIFOL’s statutes concerning the admission of new members, but the judge ruled that this issue had not been properly included in his claims and therefore could not be considered.
With the substantive objections withdrawn, the court dismissed Thompson’s claims and ordered him to pay Cg. 1,500 in litigation costs.
Court Rejects Thompson’s Explanation About Union Property
WIFOL, Richardson and Jones had filed a counterclaim seeking the return of union property and access to its administration.
They argued that Thompson had maintained exclusive control over important organizational resources, including keys, financial records, bank account access and digital credentials.
According to their submissions, the newly elected board found little more than a few binders at WIFOL’s offices.
Thompson maintained that he no longer possessed any WIFOL property and that everything previously in his possession had been left at the union’s premises.
The judge was unconvinced.
The court noted that Thompson had previously indicated, through correspondence dated September 29, that he was willing to discuss temporary joint management or a transfer of property under protest.
No evidence was presented that he had subsequently handed over the relevant property.
Furthermore, during the hearing, Thompson argued that passwords providing access to WIFOL’s administration and bank accounts belonged to him personally.
The judge rejected that position, finding that Thompson appeared to possess the passwords but was wrongfully withholding them from the new board.
The court also noted that Thompson acknowledged during the hearing that he still possessed certain keys to WIFOL’s premises.
Taken together, these circumstances led the judge to reject Thompson’s claim that he no longer retained union property.
Seven Days to Surrender Property and Records
The court ordered Thompson to surrender, within seven days of the November 13 judgment:
- All keys, access devices, alarm codes and passwords relating to WIFOL’s buildings, offices, safes and vehicles.
- Financial records, membership registers, corporate and tenant files, stamps, seals, computers, laptops, hard drives and other equipment.
- Login credentials for the association’s accounts.
- Documents, files and other WIFOL property removed from its premises by Thompson or Ms. Lisa Alexander on or around September 17, 2026.
Thompson must also provide the new board with full access to WIFOL’s bank accounts, financial administration and digital accounts.
The court emphasized that, where cooperation from third parties such as banks is required, Thompson must take the necessary steps to facilitate that cooperation.
The judge also rejected Thompson’s argument that an inventory was needed before he could identify what should be returned, noting that his lengthy tenure as chairman meant he could reasonably be expected to possess the relevant records.
Immediate Prohibition and Financial Penalties
The judgment prohibits Thompson from presenting himself as a WIFOL representative, director or chairman before union members, the Chamber of Commerce, banks, foundations or other third parties.
He is also prohibited from carrying out legal acts on behalf of the organization.
This prohibition took immediate effect.
Failure to comply with the court’s orders can result in a penalty of Cg. 2,500 per day, subject to a maximum of Cg. 50,000.
The court also ordered Thompson to pay an additional Cg. 1,500 in costs relating to WIFOL’s counterclaim, bringing the total awarded litigation costs to Cg. 3,000.
Not all of WIFOL’s requests were granted.
The court declined to order the surrender of unspecified funds or disclosure of certain transactions involving WIFOL and other foundations because those demands had not been sufficiently detailed for determination in summary proceedings.
Judgment Immediately Enforceable
The court declared its judgment provisionally enforceable, meaning the orders may be executed even if an appeal is filed.
The ruling establishes the immediate obligations arising from the leadership dispute and clears the way for the newly elected WIFOL board to seek control of the association’s administration, accounts and property.
The judgment does not establish whether Thompson has complied with the handover requirements since its delivery.
The case was heard under number SXM202601177 and the judgment was pronounced in open court on November 13, 2026, by Judge G. Konings.
###
Related article:
Editorial
###
ADVERTISEMENT









