Advertisement
The April 1st parliamentary meeting that began as a routine presentation by Minister of Public Housing, Spatial Planning, Environment and Infrastructure (VROMI) Patrice Gumbs quickly escalated into a session marked by pointed questions and critical commentary from Members of Parliament, culminating in the formal submission of a Motion of No Confidence by MP Lyndon Lewis.
The motion submitted by Lewis calls for the immediate resignation of Minister Gumbs, citing what he described as ongoing failures in governance, infrastructure management, and public service delivery. It is supported by Egbert Doran, representing the National Alliance (NA), and Omar Ottley of the United People’s (UP) party.
Lewis, representing the Nation, Opportunity and Wealth (NOW) party, opened his remarks by stressing that, despite detailed presentations by the minister, the reality on the ground tells a very different story. He cited the minister’s own admission that certain laws, including those governing garbage disposal, are not being properly enforced.
“The bare minimum is not being executed,” Lewis said. “This is not just about policy; it’s about delivering results to the people of St. Maarten.”
He also criticized the continued absence of two senior civil servants, who remain at home while receiving full salaries, describing it as a drain on public resources and a factor negatively affecting the ministry’s operational capacity.
“The country is suffering under the leadership of this current minister,” Lewis added. “Effective governance requires more than vision; it requires active management of personnel and resources.”
Lewis further highlighted complaints from residents about a lack of communication from the ministry. He said letters and requests sent to the minister often go unanswered, a situation he described as disrespectful and emblematic of a broader disconnect between government and citizens.
Infrastructure concerns
During the session in Parliament, Lewis highlighted examples of neglect in local communities, pointing to areas where garbage has accumulated, creating unsanitary conditions. He referenced locations near Nazareth, where children are exposed to flies and uncollected waste.
“Who is to blame? It is the current minister,” Lewis stated, emphasizing that sanitation and public health are core responsibilities of the ministry.
Road conditions were another major focus. Lewis noted widespread deterioration and highlighted stretches between Illidge Road and Bush Road where abandoned vehicles remain unaddressed. “The minister himself should take initiative—drive around and see what needs to be done,” he said, underscoring the need for hands-on leadership.
Environmental concerns were also raised, including the state of the landfill and the spread of garbage into surrounding areas, such as into the Great Salt Pond. Lewis warned of the risks this poses to both public health and the environment.
Economic issues
The motion also addresses broader structural and economic concerns. Lewis criticized delays in building permits, which he said are stifling development and harming the construction sector, a key driver of St. Maarten’s economy.
“There are 1,200 homes planned, yet permits aren’t being signed for even one,” he said. He also raised concerns about the lack of clear frameworks for economic activity, insufficient transparency regarding infrastructure projects, and the absence of a strategic plan for drainage and road maintenance.
Additionally, Lewis accused the minister of failing to attract foreign investment, further contributing to stagnation in economic growth and missed opportunities for national development.
Doran: Accountability and social impact
MP Egbert Doran, former Minister of VROMI, reinforced Lewis’s concerns during the first round of questions. He highlighted the expiration of district cleaning contracts, which left over 100 workers unemployed overnight.
“Right now the minister has single-handedly added over 100 individuals to unemployment,” Doran said. “This could have been avoided with timely tendering or temporary extensions, but it wasn’t.”
Doran also raised concerns about road maintenance, citing a serious accident involving police officers as an example of consequences stemming from inaction. “The minister knew about the problem… and did absolutely nothing,” he said.
He further criticized the delayed garbage collection tender process and questioned why allocated funds for infrastructure projects have not been utilized. “Funds are there, no projects being executed,” Doran stated.
Ottley: Leadership and responsibility
MP Omar Ottley focused on accountability and leadership style. “The minister has passed the buck,” Ottley said. “It wasn’t me, it was someone else… then it’s the people. That’s all I am hearing.” He stressed that effective leadership requires owning both successes and failures.
Ottley also raised concerns about economic stagnation caused by delayed permits and projects. “Day by day, complaints keep coming in about people not receiving permits,” he said. He warned that unemployment and lack of opportunity could have serious social consequences.
Environmental and public health issues, including overflowing garbage and poor road conditions, were also highlighted as critical problems requiring immediate attention.
Motion formally tabled
Following these interventions, MP Lewis formally presented the Motion of No Confidence against Minister Gumbs. He emphasized that the motion is about governance, not personal grievances.
The motion has been officially submitted and will be registered and circulated among Members of Parliament. A follow-up session will be scheduled to allow Minister Gumbs to respond to the concerns raised.
###
ADVERTISEMENT
